「你有多大可能把这门强化课推荐给正在准备 USNCO 或学有机化学的朋友?」
没有一份回答低于 8 分。数据来自完成课程结束反馈问卷的全部 9 位直播课学生和 2 位录播学生。
11 份回答在 0 到 10 分上的分布:0 位学生打了 0 分; 0 位学生打了 1 分; 0 位学生打了 2 分; 0 位学生打了 3 分; 0 位学生打了 4 分; 0 位学生打了 5 分; 0 位学生打了 6 分; 0 位学生打了 7 分; 2 位学生打了 8 分; 3 位学生打了 9 分; 6 位学生打了 10 分。
另外一道题用来校准这一周的强度:11 位学生中有 7 位认为习题比一般课程更难,但没有任何一位把节奏、难度或作业量评为两端的极值。
什么最有帮助
每位学生最多选三项。
- 讲课9/11
- 课后习题6/11
- 挑战题5/11
- 概念复习卷4/11
- 提交后看详解3/11
- 额外练习卷2/11
- 课堂答疑2/11
- 结课考试1/11
- 课前小测1/11
结课时仍然没把握的内容
多选题。没有人选「都掌握了」——五天能打下基础,谈不上精通。
- 消除反应(E1/E2)10/11
- 取代反应(SN1/SN2)7/11
- 烯烃加成6/11
- 烷烃、异构体与构象3/11
- 反应活性与机理3/11
- 立体化学2/11
- 结构与成键1/11
- 酸碱1/11
- 没有——都掌握了0/11
学生自己的话
一周前做不到、现在做得到的事
以下引用来自课程结束时的反馈问卷,按英文原文刊出,仅在长度上做轻微删减。学生只标注年级和所在州。
I did self-study O Chem last year for USNCO, but it was more passive learning because I just read some textbooks, and during the local and national ones I kind of just went with my gut feeling because I wasn't practicing the problems a lot. This program gave me a more structured approach with more practice problems to apply skills.A LOT. E1, SN1, SN2, E2 reactions. I finally understood chirality, and now I can identify chiral molecules. Chair conformations of cyclohexane really helped, and now I'm able to draw those as well as identify the best form.I am now capable of answering the majority of the organic chemistry questions on USNCO exams, and I understand the concept of resonance and resonance structures to a much better extent. I am able to detect common patterns between different topics, to make educated guesses for concepts I may not be too familiar with.这一周的感受
I didn't know anything about organic chemistry before this class, so except the AP Chemistry review sections everything was new to me. The workload was challenging but it was also rewarding, and the quiz-lecture-problem set rhythm helped me retain the concepts well.I think I learned a lot in this class, not just about organic chemistry but also USNCO problem solving skills. I liked the constant problem sets, and the USNCO-styled questions pulled directly from different chemistry olympiads were a good challenge for me.The pacing was good, with various questions being covered and answered. The depth of the discussions was very comprehensive. The problem set rhythm was reasonable and intensive without being overwhelming.The week was fast and intensive and very useful in learning organic chemistry. The problem sets and practice reinforced the lectures, and doing hundreds of questions drilled in the concepts. The workload was heavy, but it was heavy in a good way.Because I decided to go with the recording option for the lectures, the pace felt a little more relaxed — I was able to self-correct for the time I needed on a specific topic.突然想通的那一刻
My most memorable moment was during our lecture on hydrogenation, looking at that diagram drawn on the lecture notes — how the H2 molecules essentially act as radicals on the surface of the metal, attacking the pi bond two at a time. That visual, of the hydrogens sitting as little bumps on the metal surface, made it a lot easier to understand the mechanism.Doing challenge problem #3 on the reactivities and mechanisms homework — the long arrow-pushing one. The one we did in class I wasn't too confident about and we did together, but doing this problem on my own was very satisfying, just to see the overall reaction.据此改进
2027 年会改什么
征求批评是为了真的去用。下面每一条都直接来自这届学生写下的意见。
- 1
取代与消除反应讲得更多,也开始得更早
11 位学生中有 10 位把 E1/E2 列为仍然没把握的内容,7 位列了 SN1/SN2。这两块正好排在第 4–5 天,也是好几位学生反映节奏最紧的时候;还有一位直接提出,前期基础可以少讲一些,反应机理要多讲。
- 2
不饱和度公式提前到头两天讲
做异构体计数题的学生说,这个公式讲到一半才出现,那时他们已经在这类题上卡了很久。
- 3
书面详解写短一些,挑战题标注难度
学生认为详解有用,但太长了,回头不好再看一遍;他们也希望知道挑战题该从哪一道开始做。
- 4
每节课后发一份书面小结,另附进阶专题阅读清单
课上口头讲过的内容——消除反应中的共平面要求、自由基反应——课后只靠笔记很难还原。
- 5
重做课前小测和讲义填空
课前小测在 11 位学生中只被选了 1 次,和结课考试并列最低;还有几位学生说,讲课节奏快的时候讲义上的空来不及填。
他们接下来想要什么
他们最想先拿到哪些专题卷
问到接下来想要哪些选择题专题卷时,11 位学生中有 7 位七个专题全选,而且每一位都选了 USNCO 风格综合复习。
- USNCO 风格综合复习11/11
- 芳香化学9/11
- 羧酸及其衍生物9/11
- 波谱与结构鉴定9/11
- 醇与醚8/11
- 醛与酮8/11
- 胺7/11
I could treat each packet as a problem set to do after each chapter, and do them to the best of my ability. I hope that with repeated practice and reading, I will be able to advance to the USNCO national level.I'm using the packets to review before USNCO Locals and Nationals — going back to the questions I struggled with or got wrong, and completing the ones I didn't get to. My goal is to make Honors next year.The packets would really help me study ALL of o-chem so I could make it to camp and win other competitions.I plan to review the packets and look for similar practice problems, along with using them to study for USNCO Locals.错过了这一周?完整录播仍然可以购买。
这届学生做过的全部内容——20 小时授课(共 5 天)、9 节讲义填空课、18 份小测与习题、18 份概念复习卷与额外练习卷、1 场综合结课考试——就是上面他们评价的那套材料,按你自己的节奏学。
关于这些数字
所有上直播课的学生都填写了结课反馈问卷,另有 2 位录播学生也填写了——共 11 份回答。本页每一项数字都标注了分母。问卷通过 Google Form 提交,明确要求提出批评,是否提交与答案是否正面无关。引用的原话只做长度上的删减和拼写规范,措辞未改;学生只标注年级和所在州。学生原话按英文原文刊出。